Dublin Web Summit thoughts part 1: Investor Summit – do your VCs add value?

by Simon Murdoch

On the afternoon of day two of the Dublin Web Summit, Paul and I attended the Investor Summit at the Intercontinental Hotel next door to the main event*.

The Investor Summit had two roundtable sessions with the following interesting questions being debated by c 10-20 investors in each roundtable group.

Screen Shot 2015-11-05 at 15.22.22

Screen Shot 2015-11-05 at 15.22.32

For us, this was a very interesting and useful forum – being thrown together with other investors from around the world – mainly VCs and mainly from Europe, but with others in the mix too from US, from the LP side (ie investors in VCs rather than VCs themselves), advisory and so on.

A couple of useful things struck us. The first was about the mindset of how a VC should add value to the investee company.

In the roundtable discussing: “They aren’t all going to go public: Navigating portfolio companies through M&A”, the group of VCs seemed to be very focussed on financial engineering. That is, in the situation where a company was underachieving and the shareholders would rather go for a trade sale sooner rather than later, the investors were all discussing deal terms. That is: how to structure terms for providing the runway to allow a sale, how to ensure investor and retained management are incentivised – usually at the expense of other shareholders of course.

Paul raised the question obvious to us: how can we give operational help to our companies to avoid these situations in the first place or fix the situation when it arises. The other VCs in the group didn’t seem to understand the question. It brought it home to us that many VCs focus on doing a great job at selection and leave all aspects of running the companies to the management.

We believe our role is also to mentor management and especially the CEO. We want to add operational experience and value to our companies (without of course working there as we only have limited time per company).

It’s a bit like the old Irish joke where a guy asks someone by the side of the road: “How do you get to Dublin?” and the local replies: “I wouldn’t start from here”.

For us the first step is at all times to help our CEOs think through what has to be proved by when. We should all know when the cash is going to run out way ahead of that time and be considering course corrections, at every board meeting if necessary.

Of course some of our companies end up in difficult situations – they can run out of cash before they have proved enough to attract new investors – but we will have had months of warning about this and will already have tried lots of fixes including providing operational help to the management either ourselves or more likely by introducing others who can make a material difference, or recommending changes of approach which can solve the problems.

[Note to entrepreneurs at Web Summit you pay for a stand for one day out of the three. The traffic of professional investors will be much lower on the day of the Investor Summit than on the other days – to get value for money for your stand, try to avoid that day – this year the second day – the Wednesday]

Note also: other learnings from Dublin Web Summit to follow soon…

Suggested Articles

Is your start up a business or a pet project?
by Simon Murdoch

This week was VentureFest Bristol & Bath. I was on a panel of investors at a session called the Investor Showcase asking questions of the 12 winners selected from over 45 local start up companies. As well as those 12, there were about 40 other companies exhibiting in a Web Summit style i.e. with tiny stands. I walked around and spoke to a few of them too.     Most of the questions from me and the other panelists were about…

Do VCs like Episode 1 worry about competition?
by Simon Murdoch

There’s a lot of new money coming into early stage VC in the UK at the moment. Congratulations to Harry Briggs, Rory Stirling and Simon Calver for their £200m/$300m Business Growth Fund backed early stage fund which leaked a couple of days ago. Congrats too to Passion Capital whose second Enterprise Capital Fund of £45m/$69m was announced last week. Mosaic Ventures announced $140m a few months ago and DN Capital closed their fund of $200m around the same time too….

Episode 1 advice on board meetings
by Simon Murdoch

I’ve been on about 30 boards in my time. A good board can really drive a company to greatness, a bad board is a pain for all concerned. Here’s the advice we give our entrepreneurs about board meetings when we first invest… Board meetings can be incredibly useful for you – if they have the right content and the right people in the board . We’ll discuss the structure & content of the board pack and of the meetings themselves…

How does Episode 1 help its entrepreneurs?
by Adrian Lloyd

How we help Entrepreneurs What makes smart money smart? That’s the question every entrepreneur needs to ask themselves when raising money. If you’re good, you’ll have funding options and you’ll need to decide which deal to accept. It’s not just about the valuation – you should also consider the value added by the investor (as well as the dilution percentage, the detailed terms etc). You should certainly consider lower valuation offers from an investor who you really rate, as they…

Meet Frank
by Damien Lane

One of the great things about a start-up is the opportunity to do things differently. My partners Simon, Adrian and Ash have all started their own businesses before, and while I have not, we all share an aspiration to try to improve the environment and make some small contribution to the way in which the London VC scene works. We are doing this by introducing our most important – if slightly mysterious – partner, Frank. Frank comes to every meeting…


Website by

We Are Ignition